Skip to content 
If you’ve just moved into a house in Farmington Hills, taken over a storefront in Birmingham, or misplaced a set of keys somewhere in Detroit, you’re probably wondering the same thing: is it smarter to rekey the locks or replace them entirely? The answer depends on your security priorities, the condition of your hardware, and how you manage access for family, tenants, or staff. This guide breaks down both options in plain English, so you can make a confident decision that fits your budget and keeps your property secure.
What “rekeying” really means
Rekeying changes the internal pin configuration of a lock so that old keys stop working and a new key becomes the only valid one. The exterior hardware stays on your door, so there’s no change to the look and feel of the lock. For Michigan homeowners and landlords, rekeying is often the fastest way to restore key control after a move, a tenant turnover, or a lost key. Because it reuses your existing hardware, it’s typically more affordable than a full replacement and can be completed in a single visit. If the lock brand and cylinder type are compatible across multiple doors, rekeying also lets you set those doors to the same key, which is convenient for garages, side entries, and basement walkouts.
When replacement is the smarter choice
Replacement means removing your current hardware and installing new locks. It’s the right move when the existing lock is damaged, corroded, or showing signs of wear like sticking, wobbling, or poor latch alignment. It’s also ideal if you want to raise the level of physical security with high-security cylinders, restricted keyways that prevent unauthorized duplication, or modern smart locks with keypads and app control. For businesses across Canton, Bloomfield, and Detroit, replacement is common during remodels or when upgrading to commercial-grade lever sets, panic bars, or Grade 1 deadbolts that better handle heavy foot traffic.
A practical decision framework
Start with key control. If your main concern is that old keys might still be floating around—with previous owners, contractors, or past employees—rekeying solves the problem quickly and economically. Next, assess hardware conditions. If the lock binds, the key catches, or the bolt doesn’t throw cleanly, you’ll get more long-term value replacing it with a durable, serviceable model. Consider security objectives. If you’re worried about forced entry, choose locksets with hardened inserts, reinforced strike plates, and longer screws that anchor into the door frame; these upgrades usually happen during replacement. Then think about convenience. If you want code access for cleaners, dog walkers, or staff on rotating schedules, a keypad or smart lock might be worth it. Finally, aesthetics matter. Replacement allows you to match finishes and styles during a renovation so the hardware looks intentional, not patched together.
How costs, time, and disruption compare
Rekeying generally costs less than replacing, especially if you have several locks that can be re-pinned during the same appointment. It’s also faster because there’s no need to drill new holes or adjust door prep. Replacement requires more time on site, particularly if you’re moving to different hardware footprints, upgrading to longer bolts, or reinforcing strike plates. The payoff is a fresh warranty, stronger security, and, in the case of smart locks, the convenience of codes and app-based control. For many Michigan clients, the best approach is mixed: rekey interior and secondary doors for speed and savings, while replacing a worn or high-risk exterior lock with a high-security or smart model.
Michigan factors that influence the choice
Michigan’s temperature swings can exaggerate small alignment issues. A door that swells in humidity or shifts slightly on its hinges can cause marginal hardware to bind. If a lock has been sticking seasonally, rekeying alone won’t fix a misaligned strike; a replacement paired with alignment and reinforcement will. Older homes in Detroit and surrounding suburbs often have a mix of lock brands from different eras. Rekeying them to a single key may or may not be possible, depending on cylinder compatibility. On newer builds in Farmington Hills, standardizing to one key across multiple entries is usually straightforward. For short-term rentals or student housing, smart locks with time-limited codes reduce key handoffs and simplify turnover without sacrificing accountability.
Smart locks versus traditional high-security
Smart locks excel at access management. Codes can be added or revoked without meeting in person, and temporary codes keep vendors and guests on a schedule. That said, batteries must be maintained, and some models rely on reliable Wi-Fi or Bluetooth for remote features. Traditional high-security locks deliver predictable physical resistance against bumping, drilling, and picking and require no batteries or connectivity. A popular, balanced setup is a high-security deadbolt paired with a smart lever or keypad. You get robust physical protection at the deadbolt and day-to-day code convenience at the latch, which suits busy households and small businesses alike.
Residential scenarios we see every week
After a closing or a move-in across Farmington Hills or Birmingham, most new owners opt for a full rekey so every old key stops working. If the hardware is in good shape and the finishes match, there’s no reason to replace. When locks are dated, inconsistent, or visibly worn, it makes sense to replace the most exposed exterior door with a stronger deadbolt and reinforce the strike plate with longer screws into the framing. For families that prefer fewer keys on the ring, rekeying multiple exterior and garage-to-house doors to a single key simplifies daily life. If you’re ready to schedule residential service.
Business use cases where the decision is clear
For offices and retail spaces in Canton, Bloomfield, and Detroit, staff turnover is a constant. Rekeying promptly after role changes keeps access under control without replacing the whole system. When you need layered access—front door, back hallway, stockroom, server room—a master key system built on compatible cylinders is usually the best choice, and rekeying implements it quickly. If your hardware is mismatched or doesn’t meet your durability needs, replacement with commercial-grade locks is worth the investment. For businesses concerned about key duplication, restricted keyways limit where and how keys can be copied. If you’re evaluating options for your location, start here: Commercial Locksmith.
What to expect during a professional visit
A technician begins with a walkthrough to inspect the door slab, hinges, strike alignment, and the lock brand and condition. If rekeying is chosen, cylinders are removed, re-pinned to new combinations, and tested with the new keys. If replacement is chosen, the pro verifies the backset and door prep, fits the new lock, aligns the latch and strike, and reinforces the frame where appropriate. The goal is a smooth, consistent key turn, a deadbolt that throws fully, and a latch that aligns without forcing. At the end, you’ll receive the new keys or codes, basic lubrication guidance, and any warranty information for the hardware. For urgent needs—lockouts or broken keys—use our round-the-clock line: Emergency Locksmith.
A word on key control and documentation
Households, landlords, and managers benefit from simple key control practices. Label keys discreetly without full addresses, record how many copies exist, and decide who may authorize new duplicates. For businesses, a light key policy clarifies who holds master keys, where restricted keys are stored, and how access changes are requested. Smart locks make this easier by generating time-bound codes and audit trails, while restricted mechanical systems make unauthorized duplication harder. Whether you choose rekeying or replacement, a little documentation prevents confusion later, especially during busy seasons or staff transitions.
Preparing for the appointment
Before your locksmith arrives, confirm which doors you want addressed, clear access on both sides of those doors, and check whether any doors stick or drag so the technician can correct alignment. If you’re considering smart locks, decide if you prefer keypad only or app-enabled features and whether all users will be comfortable with codes. If your aim is one-key convenience, gather the existing keys you have; even if some are missing, rekeying eliminates old copies, but knowing what’s out there helps the planning.
Choosing the right partner
Look for consistent contact information across your website and Google Business Profile, marked vehicles, clear identification on arrival, and straightforward pricing. Ask which brands and grades your locksmith recommends for front entries that take the brunt of weather and wear. A professional will explain why a particular deadbolt, strike reinforcement, or smart model suits your door and risk profile, not just the cheapest or flashiest option. If you’re comparing rekeying versus replacement, expect a direct explanation of total cost, long-term durability, and the trade-offs that matter to you—whether it’s security, aesthetics, or ease of use for multiple occupants.
The balanced recommendation
There’s no one answer for every property, but a practical approach works well across Michigan homes and businesses: rekey to regain key control quickly, replace any locks that are worn or strategically important, and consider a targeted upgrade to a high-security deadbolt or a smart lever where convenience and accountability matter. This combination keeps costs sensible while meaningfully improving security and day-to-day use.
